Menu

Regular Sized Cupcakes

$16.00 per dozen
$8.00 per half-dozen

Flavors Available to Order

Classic Vanilla – Vanilla cake with Vanilla Buttercream
Classic Chocolate – Chocolate cake with Chocolate Buttercream
Tuxedo – Chocolate Cake with Vanilla Buttercream
Zebras – Vanilla Cake with Chocolate Buttercream
Lemon & Vanilla Cream – Lemon Cake with Vanilla Buttercream
Lemon & Chocolate Cream – Lemon Cake with Chocolate Buttercream
Strawberries & Cream – Strawberry Cake with Vanilla Buttercream
Chocolate Covered Strawberry – Strawberry Cake with Chocolate Buttercream
Scarlet & Cream – Red Velvet Cake with Vanilla Buttercream
Chocolate Velvet – Red Velvet Cake with Chocolate Buttercream
Butterfinger – Vanilla Cake topped with Butterfinger Buttercream
Oreo – Chocolate Cake with Oreo Buttercream
Chocolate Malt – Chocolate Cake with Chocolate Malt Buttercream
Toffee Bar – Chocolate Cake with Toffee Bar Buttercream
Peanut Butter Cup – Chocolate Cake with a Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup Buttercream
Twix – Vanilla Cake with Twix Buttercream
Coconut Dream – Chocolate Cake with Coconut Buttercream
Coconut Lemon – Lemon Cake with Coconut Buttercream
Snickers – Vanilla Cake with Snickers Buttercream
Lemon Burst – Lemon Cake with Lemon Buttercream
Strawberry Lemonade – Strawberry Cake with Lemon Buttercream
Strawberry Mango – Strawberry Cake with Mango Buttercream
Blue Raspberry – Vanilla Cake with Blue Raspberry Buttercream
Chocolate Mint Cookie – Chocolate Cake with Chocolate Mint Cookie Buttercream
Maple Pecan – Vanilla Cake with Maple Pecan Buttercream
Maple Walnut – Vanilla Cake with Maple Walnut Buttercream
Cookie Dough – Chocolate Cake with Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Buttercream
Cinnamon Roll – Vanilla Cake with Cinnamon Roll Buttercream
Orange Cream – Vanilla Cake with Orange Buttercream
Dark Chocolate Orange – Chocolate Cake with Orange Buttercream
Root Beer Float – Vanilla Cake with Root Beer Buttercream
Mint Chip – Chocolate Cake with Mint Chip Buttercream
Peanut Butter Cookie – Vanilla Cake with Peanut Butter Cookie Buttercream
Cherry Cordial – Chocolate Cake with Cherry Cordial Buttercream
Candy Cane – Vanilla Cake with Candy Cane Buttercream
Coffee & Cream – Vanilla Cake with Coffee Buttercream
Mocha – Chocolate Cake with Coffee Buttercream
Peanut Butter – Chocolate Cake with Peanut Butter Buttercream
Key Lime Pie – Vanilla Cake with Key Lime Pie Buttercream
Caramel – Chocolate Cake with Caramel Buttercream
Pumpkin Pie – Vanilla Cake with Pumpkin Pie Buttercream
3 Musketeers – Chocolate Cake with a 3 Musketeers Buttercream
Carrot Cake – Carrot Cake with Cream Cheese Icing
Red Velvet w/Cream Cheese – Red Velvet Cake with Cream Cheese Icing
Vanilla Chocolate Chip – Vanilla Cake baked with Chocolate Chips topped with Vanilla Buttercream
Triple Chocolate - Chocolate Cake baked with Chocolate Chips topped with Chocolate Buttercream
Banana Cream – Banana Cake with Vanilla Buttercream
Wedding Cake – Almond Cake with Vanilla Buttercream
PB & J – Vanilla Cake topped with Peanut Butter Buttercream and a Grape Jelly drizzle
Hazelnut – Vanilla Cake topped with a Hazelnut Buttercream
Pumpkin Cream Cheese – Vanilla Cake topped with a Pumpkin Pie Cream Cheese Icing
Carrot Coconut Cream Cheese Bliss – Carrot Cake topped with a Coconut Cream Cheese Icing
Peppermint Patty – Chocolate cake topped with peppermint buttercream and drenched in chocolate ganache.

German Chocolate – A light German Chocolate cake topped with a coconut-pecan buttercream. PJ’s delicious twist on a classic!

Peanut Butter Blossoms – Vanilla or Chocolate cake topped with Peanut Butter Cookie Buttercream and finished with a Kiss!

Almond Joy – “Sometimes you feel like a nut!” Chocolate Cake with Coconut Buttercream topped with Almonds and drizzled with chocolate ganache.

Mounds – “Sometimes you don’t!” Chocolate Cake with Coconut Buttercream and drizzled with chocolate ganache.

Cranberry Walnut – Vanilla Cake with Cranberry Walnut Buttercream. Flavor available November & December only.

Nebraska “Fancakes” – Chocolate or Vanilla Cupcakes topped with Vanilla or Chocolate Buttercream and finished with a monogrammed “N” Fondant Topper.  Please provide at least a week notice for orders of Fancakes!
Samoa – Vanilla Cake topped with a Samoa Cookie Buttercream, toasted coconut and chocolate drizzle
Dutch Apple Pie – Vanilla Cake topped with an Apple Buttercream and finished with a homemade streusel topping
Blueberry Pie – Vanilla Cake topped with a real Blueberry Buttercream and finished with a homemade streusel topping
Cherry Pie – Vanilla Cake topped with a real Cherry Buttercream and finished with a homemade streusel topping
Lemon Meringue Pie – Lemon Cake filled with a homemade lemon curd and topped with a toasted meringue
Sweet Potato Pie – Vanilla Cake topped with a Sweet Potato Buttercream and toasted marshmallows
Raspberry Lemonade – Lemon Cake topped with a real Raspberry Buttercream
Pineapple – Vanilla Cake topped with a real Pineapple Buttercream
Salted Caramel – Chocolate Cake topped with a Salted Caramel Buttercream, dipped in chocolate ganache sprinkled with sea salt
Mexican Hot Chocolate – Chocolate Cake topped with a Spicy Chili-Chocolate Buttercream
Blueberry Pancake – Vanilla Cake topped with a real Blueberry Buttercream and drizzled in a Maple Glaze
Butterbeer – A buttery cream-soda cake filled with a Butterscotch Ganache and topped with a Butterscotch Buttercream and finished with a Butterscotch Ganache drizzle. Accio Cupcake!
Sir Scotch-a-Lot – Vanilla Cake topped with a Butterscotch Buttercream and Macadamia Nuts
French Silk – Chocolate cake topped with a light and fluffy French Silk Chocolate Buttercream and finished with chocolate shavings
Supreme Cookies & Cream – Cookies & Cream cake topped with a Cream Cheese icing and finished with Oreo cookie crumbs
Whipped Honey – Vanilla cake topped with a Whipped Honey Buttercream and finished with a honey drizzle
Cherry Walnut – Vanilla cake topped with a real cherry buttercream and finished with chopped walnuts
Strawberry Pomegranate – Strawberry cake topped with a Pomegranate Buttercream
Banana Chocolate Walnut – Banana cake topped with Chocolate Buttercream, chopped walnuts and drizzled with White Chocolate Ganache
“Quatro” Chocolate – 4 times the chocolate in one cupcake! Chocolate cake filled AND topped with Chocolate Buttercream & drizzled with chocolate ganache!
“Quatro> Vanilla – Quadruple the Vanilla! Vanilla cake filled AND topped with Vanilla Buttercream and sprinkled with Vanilla chips.
White Chocolate – Chocolate cake topped with a fluffy White Chocolate Buttercream and finished with White Chocolate shavings
Neapolitan – Strawberry cake topped with Vanilla AND Chocolate Buttercream!
Spumoni – A popular Italian dessert turned cupcake! Cherry cake topped with Pistachio Buttercream and finished with a Maraschino Cherry.
The Zinger – Our moist Strawberry cake filled with vanilla buttercream and topped with Coconut cream icing.

Irish Bombs – You don’t have to wait until March 17th to be Irish with this cupcake! Our moist dark chocolate cake infused with the famous Guinness Irish stout, filled with a rich and decadent Irish Whiskey chocolate ganache, and topped with a light and fluffy Irish Cream Buttercream.

The Madison – Named after the street where our store is located, we’ve taken our moist dark chocolate cake and filled with vanilla buttercream, topped it with a chocolate ganache topping and finished it with a vanilla buttercream “curly-q” design. Our delicious take on the famous cupcake it’s inspired by.

Margarita – Viva Mexico! A moist white cake infused with tequila and margarita mix, topped with a lime buttercream and finished with a sugared rim or a candy lime.

Turtle – AKA “The Cole” – Our Dark Chocolate cake topped with a caramel buttercream, pecan pieces and a chocolate and caramel drizzle.

The King – PJ’s homage to Elvis! Banana cake topped with Peanut Butter Buttercream and finished with a banana chip!

Strawberry Daiquiri – Strawberry Cake spiked with Rum and topped with Vanilla Buttercream.

Piña Colada – Pineapple Cake spiked with Rum and topped with Coconut Buttercream.

Caramel Apple – A Fall favorite! Vanilla cake topped with our caramel buttercream, chopped nuts, dried apples and a caramel drizzle!

Double Dippers – If you like The Madison, you’re going to love these! Chocolate Cake filled with Vanilla Buttercream, dipped in chocolate ganache and then dipped again in Oreo cookie crumbs!

Caramel Nut Sundae – Vanilla cake with our Classic Vanilla Buttercream topped with a caramel drizzle, chopped nuts and finished with a maraschino cherry

Fudge Nut Sundae – Vanilla cake with our Classic Vanilla Buttercream topped with our homemade fudge sauce, chopped nuts and finished with a maraschino cherry

Rocky Road – Dark Chocolate cake with Chocolate Buttercream topped with chopped nuts and marshmallows

S’Mores – Vanilla cake with Chocolate Buttercream topped with graham crackers and marshmallows

Chocolate Covered Cherries – Dark Chocolate cake with Cherry Cordial Buttercream topped with a chocolate covered cherry!

Worms ‘n’ Dirt – Chocolate cake with chocolate buttercream topped with crushed oreo crumbs and a gummy worm. A classic kid favorite but perfect for all ages!

Strawberry Deluxe – Our moist strawberry cake topped with a creamy strawberry buttercream made with real strawberries! *Fondant flowers are an additional $6.00/dozen.

Vegan/Dairy Free Cupcakes – A dairy and egg free chocolate cake topped with a dairy free vanilla icing. *Please provide a full weeks notice for these cupcakes.

Eggnog – New Seasonal Flavor! Eggnog flavored cake topped with a Buttered Rum Buttercream. Flavor available November & December only.

Filled

Filled Cupcakes must be ordered in a minimum of 6 per flavor/design

1. Choose your cake flavor
2. Choose your icing flavor to fill it with
3. Top it (with either Buttercream Icing or a Fondant design)

Characters

Character Cupcakes must be ordered in a minimum of 6 per flavor/design

Character Cupcakes are our Classic Cupcakes with fun faces on top! Choose from ones we’ve already made or contact us for other customization options! Please provide at least a week’s notice for all Character Cupcakes. Please note: even with a full week notice, some custom work may not be accommodated.

PJ’s Poppers (mini cupcakes)

PJ’s Poppers must be ordered in increments of 12 per flavor
PJ’s Poppers
$8.00 per dozen

Classic Vanilla
Classic Chocolate
Tuxedo
Zebra
Lemon & Vanilla Cream
Lemon & Chocolate Cream
Strawberries & Cream
Chocolate Covered Strawberry
Scarlet & Cream
Chocolate Velvet
Butterfinger
Oreo
Chocolate Malt
Toffee Bar
Peanut Butter Cup
Twix
Coconut Dream
Coconut Lemon
Snickers
Lemon Burst
Strawberry Lemonade
Strawberry Mango
Blue Raspberry
Chocolate Mint Cookie
Maple Pecan
Cookie Dough
Cinnamon Roll
Orange Cream
Dark Chocolate Orange
Root Beer Float
Mint Chip
Peanut Butter Cookie
Cherry Cordial
Coffee & Cream
Mocha
Peanut Butter
Key Lime Pie
Caramel
Pumpkin Pie
3 Musketeers
Sweet Potato Pie
Raspberry Lemonade
Pineapple
Salted Caramel
Mexican Hot Chocolate
Blueberry Pancake
Butterbeer
Irish Bombs
Margarita
The King
Strawberry Daiquiri
Pina Colada
Strawberry Deluxe
Neapolitan
Whipped Honey
French Silk
Maple Walnut
Cherry Walnut
Strawberry Pomegranate
White Chocolate

Other Special Requests:

Sprinkles: Any of our Classic or Signature flavors can be topped with sprinkles for just $3.00 more per dozen! We have sprinkles in a variety of styles and colors – just indicate the color of your choice as well as the style (sugar sprinkles, jimmies, etc.) in your order. Please note that due to Health Department regulations, silver dragee’s (also known as BB’s), can not be used on your cupcakes.

Colored Icing: Our Vanilla Buttercream can be custom colored. Please add an additional $6.00/dozen for light or pastel colors and $12.00/dozen for darker colors. At this time, we are unable to create a black colored Buttercream. Please provide at least a week’s notice for custom coloring of icing.

Custom Icing Styles: If you would like your cupcake to be iced in a particular style, we can do this as well – just show us a picture of what you had in mind and we’ll let you know if it’s doable! Please add an additional $3.00/dozen for the special handling of the order if you would like this.

Fondant Decorations: A great way to customize your cupcakes to your event! We can add a small fondant accent specific to your event (any fondant work except character faces). The price per dozen for cupcakes with custom fondant work starts at $6.00/dozen (extra) and is based on the level of detail required and a quote will be provided at the time of order confirmation. Please provide at least a week’s notice for custom fondant work. Please note: even with a full week notice, some custom work may not be accommodated.

Fondant Figurines: Fondant Figurines are 3D sculptures that fit right on top of your cupcake! Figurines start at $6.00/figurine and is based on the level of detail required. A quote will be provided at the time of order confirmation. Please provide at least a week’s notice for fondant figurines. Please note: even with a full week notice, some custom work may not be accommodated.

For order instructions and to access our online ordering form, please visit our order page!